Six smarketing challenges and how to diagnose and fix each one
The most common smarketing challenge is not a personality clash or a lack of goodwill. It is unclear ownership of the lead at the handoff. Marketing believes it has delivered a qualified prospect; sales believes it has been handed a name with no buying intent. Nobody owns the moment in between, so the lead sits in limbo for three days and goes cold. Everything else that goes wrong (the finger-pointing, the dashboard arguments, the “marketing leads are rubbish” refrain) tends to flow from that gap. The six smarketing challenges below each have a diagnosable symptom, a root cause, and a fix you can implement with clear ownership and shared metrics. Work through them in order. The first one causes most of the others.
Different KPIs create a tug of war between teams
The symptom
Marketing reports a record quarter for lead volume. Sales reports its worst quarter for conversion. Both are telling the truth. Marketing hit its MQL target of 400 leads; sales closed 11 deals from those 400 and needed 25 to hit plan. In the Monday meeting, marketing points at the number of leads, sales points at the quality, and the meeting ends without either team changing what it does.
You will also see this in the hiring plan. Marketing asks for budget for a content hire to increase top-of-funnel volume. Sales asks for two more SDRs to work the leads it already has. Both requests are rational inside their own scorecard and contradictory when you look at them together.
The root cause
Marketing is measured on MQLs because MQLs are the last thing marketing fully controls. Sales is measured on closed revenue because that is what the board asks about. The two metrics are related but not the same, and the gap between them is where the conflict lives. An MQL target rewards volume. A revenue target rewards selectivity. Push both at once and you have built a system where marketing is incentivised to send more and sales is incentivised to accept less.
The fix
Establish one shared revenue number that both teams are measured against, and a joint SLA that defines what each side owes the other. The SLA is the operational part. It should state, in writing:
- Marketing will deliver X leads per month that meet the agreed qualification criteria.
- Sales will attempt contact with every accepted lead within 24 hours and log the outcome.
- Sales will provide structured rejection reasons for every lead it declines.
- Both teams will review the SLA monthly and adjust the criteria, not the targets, when reality diverges.
The shared number matters more than the SLA. If marketing’s bonus depends on closed revenue and sales’ bonus depends on closed revenue, the conversation about lead quality stops being adversarial and starts being collaborative. We have seen teams cut their MQL target by 30% and grow closed revenue by 40% within two quarters, purely because marketing stopped optimising for a number that did not matter.
A worked example
A B2B software company with 14 salespeople and 6 marketers was running marketing on a target of 500 MQLs a quarter. Sales conversion from MQL to closed was 2.1%. The company replaced the MQL target with a shared quarterly revenue target of €1.8m and rewrote the lead criteria with both teams in the room. Marketing’s new target was 260 qualified leads a quarter, roughly half the old volume but with a much tighter definition. MQL to closed conversion rose to 5.4% over two quarters. Revenue landed at €2.1m. Marketing did less work and got more credit, because the number it was measured on was the number the business actually cared about.
The MQL to SQL handoff dispute leaves leads in limbo
The symptom
Marketing passes leads to sales. Sales rejects 60% of them as unqualified. Marketing asks why, and gets answers like “not ready” or “wrong fit” that cannot be acted on. The rejected leads go nowhere. Nobody contacts them again. Three months later, one of those rejected leads buys from a competitor and everyone finds out at the same time.
You can spot this misalignment quickly by looking at your CRM for leads with no activity in the last 14 days that were never formally disqualified. If that number is more than 20% of your pipeline, you have a handoff problem.
The root cause
There is no agreed definition of what a qualified lead is, and no feedback loop to improve the definition over time. Marketing uses one set of criteria (usually firmographic fit plus some engagement signal). Sales uses another (usually “do they have a problem I can solve right now”). Neither set is written down in a place both teams have agreed to. So every rejection is a fresh argument rather than a data point.
The fix
Agree on lead definitions in a single document, then implement closed-loop rejection reasons in your CRM. The rejection reasons are the mechanism that makes the definitions improve. Sales must pick from a fixed list, not free text. A useful starting list:
- No budget authority
- Wrong company size
- Wrong industry
- No active project
- Already using a competitor
- Contact has left the company
- Genuinely not interested
Every rejection reason is a signal back to marketing. If “no budget authority” is the top reason for three months running, marketing’s targeting is wrong and the fix is at the top of the funnel, not in the handoff. If “already using a competitor” dominates, marketing needs to shift messaging toward switching cost. Review the rejection reasons monthly with both teams present. This is the single highest-leverage ritual in the whole smarketing system.
A worked example
An agency partner of ours was running a lead gen programme for a client in professional services. Sales was rejecting 55% of leads and the client was close to cancelling. We introduced a five-option rejection reason dropdown in the CRM and asked sales to log one per rejection for 30 days. The data showed that 71% of rejections were “wrong company size”, and the ICP definition marketing had been given was three years out of date. Marketing rebuilt the targeting list against the current ICP. Rejection rate dropped to 22% in six weeks, and the client renewed.
Conflicting personas and messaging confuse buyers
The symptom
Marketing’s website says the product is “for growing teams who need to scale operations”. Sales, on the call, says it is “for finance directors who need to cut reporting time”. The buyer heard one promise in the ad and a different one on the call. Trust drops. The deal slows down or dies, and neither team knows why.
A sharper way to spot this: pull five recent sales call recordings and compare the language used against the language on your homepage. If the two do not overlap by at least half, your personas are fictional.
The root cause
Marketing builds personas in isolation, often from desk research and a couple of interviews. Sales builds its own mental model of the buyer from hundreds of real conversations. The two models diverge, and there is no process to reconcile them. Personas become a marketing artefact rather than a shared operating document.
The fix
Get buyer persona sign-off from both teams. That means the head of sales reviews and approves the persona document before it goes live, and has a standing invitation to challenge it. Then review call recordings monthly, with a sample of five to ten calls, and check whether the language on the calls matches the language in the persona. Where it does not, update the persona. Where it does, use the actual call language in your ads and emails, because it is already working.
One practical trick: build a shared language bank. A single document with the exact phrases buyers use to describe their problem, pulled verbatim from calls. Marketing writes copy from that document. Sales uses it in outreach. The gap closes fast when both teams are reading from the same page.
A worked example
A SaaS client had a persona built around “operations managers at mid-market companies”. Call recordings showed that in 8 of 10 closed deals, the buyer was actually a finance director who had been asked by an operations manager to solve the problem. Marketing had been targeting the wrong person for a year. The persona was rewritten with finance as the primary buyer and operations as the champion. Marketing shifted ad targeting and email copy. Pipeline velocity improved by 34% over the following quarter, with no change to product or pricing.
Separate data and tooling create a leaky funnel
The symptom
Marketing automation says a lead was sent to sales on Tuesday. The CRM says the lead does not exist. Or it exists twice, once under a personal email and once under a work email. Or the lead exists but the activity history is empty, so the salesperson calls cold and the buyer is annoyed because they downloaded a whitepaper an hour ago. Every one of these is a lead that has effectively been lost, and none of them shows up on a dashboard.
The diagnostic is simple. Take 20 leads from last month and trace each one from first touch to current status. Count how many have a clean, complete record. If fewer than 16 do, your tooling is leaking.
The root cause
Marketing automation and CRM are not synced, or are synced in one direction only. Marketing pushes leads to the CRM but does not pull status back. Duplicate records are created because there is no unique identifier both systems agree on. Data hygiene is treated as a project rather than a routine.
The fix
One CRM as the single source of truth, with bidirectional sync to your marketing automation platform. That means:
- Every lead has a unique identifier generated at first touch and carried across both systems.
- Status changes in the CRM (accepted, rejected, converted, closed) flow back to marketing automation automatically.
- Deduplication runs on a schedule, not on an ad hoc basis, with a clear rule for which record wins.
- Field mapping is documented, so when someone changes a field name in one system the sync does not silently break.
The single source of truth rule matters because it settles ownership. If the CRM is the source of truth, sales owns the record and marketing owns the enrichment. There is no argument about which system is right. We have written before about how sales automation software fits into this pictureand the core point stands: the tooling is only as good as the agreement about what it is for.
A worked example
A manufacturing client was losing an estimated 15% of inbound leads to duplicate records and broken sync. Marketing automation was creating a new lead every time someone filled a form, even if that person was already in the CRM as an opportunity. Sales was calling people who had already been called. We consolidated to a single CRM with bidirectional sync and a deduplication rule based on email domain plus contact name. Duplicate rate fell from 23% to 4% in eight weeks. The client estimated the recovered leads were worth roughly €180k in annual pipeline.
Blame loops and status theatre replace shared rituals
The symptom
The weekly sales and marketing standup has become a status update. Marketing lists what it shipped. Sales lists what it is working on. Nobody looks at the pipeline together. When a deal is lost, the conversation turns to whose fault it was. When a lead is rejected, the same. The meeting happens every week and changes nothing.
You can tell you are in a blame loop if the same three objections come up in every meeting and none of them have an owner or a deadline. “Marketing leads are poor quality” is not an agenda item. It is a symptom of a meeting that has no pipeline focus.
The root cause
The ritual is wrong. A status meeting is for reporting. A pipeline meeting is for deciding. Most teams have the former and think they have the latter. There is no shared dashboard, so there is no shared object to look at, so the conversation defaults to opinions and blame.
The fix
Replace the status standup with a joint pipeline meeting. Same day, same time, but a different agenda and a different artefact. The artefact is one dashboard showing:
- Leads created this week, by source
- Leads accepted and rejected, with rejection reasons
- Pipeline value by stage, compared to the same week last quarter
- Deals stalled for more than 14 days, with the reason
Every stalled deal and every rejection reason gets a named owner and a date. The meeting ends when every item has an owner. That is the whole ritual. It is short, it is uncomfortable the first few times, and it works because it forces the two teams to solve the same problem in the same room.
If you want the deeper version of how to run this, our piece on aligning sales and marketing teams to boost pipeline velocity walks through the operating cadence in more detail.
A worked example
A 40-person B2B services firm replaced its Monday status call with a Wednesday pipeline meeting built around a single dashboard. The first meeting surfaced 14 stalled deals worth €340k that nobody had noticed. Nine of them were stalled because the buyer had gone quiet after a proposal, and sales had assumed marketing was going to re-engage them. Marketing had assumed the opposite. Assigning owners to each stalled deal recovered four of them within a month, worth €95k. The meeting itself takes 30 minutes.
No shared revenue plan means misaligned priorities
The symptom
Marketing’s quarterly plan is built around a product launch and a brand campaign. Sales’ quarterly plan is built around closing the deals it already has in pipeline and opening a new vertical. The two plans share no milestones. When the quarter ends, marketing reports the campaign was a success and sales reports it missed its number, and both are right. The campaign did not feed the vertical. The vertical did not benefit from the campaign.
The root cause
Marketing and sales plan in silos, with different targets, different timelines, and different definitions of what a good quarter looks like. There is no single document that both teams have signed off on and no regular review against it.
The fix
Build a joint revenue plan. One document, owned by both the head of marketing and the head of sales, with:
- A single revenue target for the quarter, broken down by segment and by source.
- The campaigns and sales initiatives that will deliver it, mapped to each other.
- Shared milestones, so both teams know what needs to be true by week 4, week 8, and week 12.
- A monthly review against the plan, with the authority to change the plan, not just report on it.
The critical part is the last one. A plan that cannot be changed mid-quarter is a forecast, not a plan. If the campaign is not producing the pipeline the vertical needs by week 4, the plan should change by week 5. That only happens if both teams own it.
A worked example
A professional services firm with €6m in annual revenue moved from separate marketing and sales plans to a single joint revenue plan. The first quarter under the new model, marketing’s biggest campaign was cut at week 5 because it was not feeding the vertical sales had prioritised. The budget was redirected to a targeted account-based programme in that vertical. The quarter closed 12% above target. The following quarter, the same joint plan process produced a 19% uplift. The plan itself was not clever. The shared ownership was.
How to run the diagnostic in a single afternoon
You do not need to fix all six misalignments at once, and trying to will overwhelm the team. Run a diagnostic first. Score each of the six on a simple 1 to 5 scale, where 1 is “we have this completely under control” and 5 is “this is actively costing us deals”. Get the head of sales and the head of marketing to score independently, then compare. The gaps between their scores are as informative as the scores themselves.
| Misalignment | Diagnostic question | Score 1 to 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Different KPIs | Do marketing and sales share a single revenue number in their objectives? | |
| Handoff dispute | Do we have written lead definitions and a closed-loop rejection reason process? | |
| Conflicting messaging | Does the language on our calls match the language on our website? | |
| Separate tooling | Is there one CRM as the source of truth with bidirectional sync? | |
| Blame loops | Does our weekly meeting end with named owners and dates on every item? | |
| No shared plan | Is there one revenue plan both teams have signed off on? |
Start with the highest combined score. Fix it, run the diagnostic again in 30 days, and move to the next one. In our experience, fixing the first two (shared KPIs and the handoff) resolves about 60% of the visible friction, because most of the other symptoms are downstream of those two.
What good looks like once the misalignments are fixed
The end state is not a team that never disagrees. It is a team where disagreement produces a decision rather than a delay. Marketing can challenge a rejection reason and sales can challenge a lead definition, and the challenge produces an update to a document both teams use. That is the whole difference between a smarketing function that works and one that just has the word on a slide.
If you want the wider context on why this matters financially, our CFO-ready case for the ROI of sales and marketing alignment covers the numbers. If you are earlier in the journey, start with the 101 explainer on what smarketing actually means before you start fixing specific misalignments. And if you want to see what a joint revenue plan looks like in practice, our alignment best practices for scaling B2B teams is the next read.
Pick the misalignment with the highest combined score from the table above. Write down the symptom you can actually see in your CRM or your last team meeting. Assign one owner. Set a date 30 days out to re-score. That is the whole first move.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common smarketing challenge?
The most common challenge is unclear ownership of leads at the handoff, which leads to disputes and lost revenue. This often stems from different KPIs and lack of agreed definitions.
How can we fix sales and marketing misalignment?
Start by diagnosing the specific misalignment using symptoms and root causes, then implement the corresponding fix such as shared metrics or joint meetings. Consistency and leadership buy-in are critical.
What metrics should we use to measure smarketing success?
Use a shared revenue number, pipeline velocity, and conversion rates at each stage. Also track lead acceptance rates and feedback loop closure to ensure alignment.
How long does it take to see results from fixing smarketing challenges?
Quick wins like improved lead handoff can show results in weeks, but cultural shifts and process changes may take a quarter or more. Regular reviews and adjustments are essential.
Next step
If this is the kind of problem you are solving right now, see how us handles it.






























